Gardeners Club The Gardeners Club is a free to join online club for everyone with an interest in gardening and gardens.
Related Articles
When it comes to summer BBQs, the age-old debate arises: charcoal or gas? Both coal (charcoal) and gas barbecues have their passionate supporters, and the right choice depends on your cooking style, taste preferences, convenience needs, and even budget. Here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons of each to help you decide which BBQ is right for your Garden.
Charcoal BBQs: The Traditional Choice
Charcoal barbecues have been around for generations and are often associated with that classic smoky flavour everyone loves.
Advantages:
- Flavor – Charcoal grills give food a smoky, intense taste that gas simply can’t replicate. Using different types of charcoal or adding wood chips can create subtle flavor variations.
- High Heat – Charcoal grills can reach higher temperatures than most gas grills, perfect for searing steaks or achieving a crispy exterior.
- Authentic Experience – Many grill enthusiasts enjoy the ritual of lighting charcoal, managing the coals, and controlling the fire. It’s part of the fun of outdoor cooking.
Disadvantages:
- Longer Prep Time – Lighting charcoal and waiting for it to reach cooking temperature can take 15–30 minutes.
- Temperature Control – It’s harder to maintain a consistent temperature compared to gas. You need practice to manage vents and coals.
- Cleaning – Charcoal leaves ash behind, which requires more post-cook cleanup.
Gas BBQs: Convenience and Control
Gas barbecues, typically powered by propane or natural gas, offer a modern approach to outdoor grilling.
Advantages:
- Quick Start – Gas grills light instantly with the push of a button and reach cooking temperatures within minutes.
- Easy Temperature Control – Built-in knobs allow precise control over heat, making it easier to cook a variety of foods evenly.
- Cleaner and Low Maintenance – No ash to clean, fewer lingering odours, and generally easier upkeep.
- Versatility – Many gas grills come with multiple burners, side burners, and rotisserie attachments, ideal for larger gatherings or more complex meals.
Disadvantages:
- Less Smoky Flavor – Gas grills don’t naturally produce the smoky taste charcoal provides. Wood chips can help, but it’s not the same.
- Higher Cost – Gas grills are generally more expensive upfront, and fuel costs can add up depending on usage.
- Bulkier Setup – Gas cylinders and hoses require space and safety precautions.
Taste Battle: Which Makes Better Food?
- Charcoal wins for traditional smoky flavor and high-heat searing. Steaks, burgers, and ribs are often considered tastier on charcoal.
- Gas wins for consistent cooking and ease of preparing delicate foods like fish or vegetables without burning.
Some grillers compromise with hybrid grills, which combine charcoal and gas for flexibility.
Convenience vs. Experience
- If you value speed, simplicity, and low maintenance, gas is the way to go.
- If you enjoy the ritual, flavor, and control over fire, charcoal will likely satisfy your grilling soul.
Environmental Considerations
- Charcoal produces more smoke and carbon emissions compared to gas.
- Gas is cleaner-burning but relies on fossil fuels.
- For eco-conscious grillers, some newer options like natural gas or pellet grills can reduce environmental impact while providing good flavor.
There’s no absolute winner — it comes down to what matters most to you:
- Flavor and tradition → Charcoal
- Convenience and control → Gas
Some avid grillers even keep both options: charcoal for weekends and special meals, gas for quick weekday dinners. Ultimately, the best BBQ is one you enjoy using, whether it’s a roaring charcoal fire or a quick-turn gas flame.
